Lyle’s rewritten half a dozen verse text message is approximately parallel into the songster text once deletion of next verse of your own latter. Lyle’s rewritten version, yet not, contains the regiment attending Kilkenny, in place of Killarney. Lyle’s track try “The fresh new Bonnie Blue Forget-Me-Perhaps not,” which had been offered into the Roentgen. An excellent. Smith’s The latest Irish Minstrel , n.d. [1825, the original, allegedly pent up, edition]. The identity of your own tune could there be given given that “The newest Maid away from Derby.” If you are Lyle’s text message “Very Peg out of Derby” is meaningless since a timeless song, we are able to make certain “Quite Peggy out of Derby” was sung in the Scotland in the 1st one-fourth of your own nineteenth century which have a book very similar to you to definitely on the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text in lieu of good chapbook otherwise broadside content appears Roy Palmer’s latest Everyman’s Book out of Ballads. ]
Cahusac into the 1788, and you will just one sheet track having songs is in two Western selections, “Peggy off Darby”, hence begins “There can be an excellent gay Captain during the Darby City”
Maybe quite prior to “Quite Peggy regarding Derby, O” try rewritten since “The fresh Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” because confirmed of the a duplicate when you look at the Peter Buchan’s MSS in the British Library, which happen to be said to go out on the 1828.
The first range and a half, nearly like men and women over, are also inside the a beneficial medley for the Vol. We, p. cuatro, 1825. You can find musical for the track “Very Peggy from Derby, O” toward p. 107 and you can 276 of Vol. III, 1828, additionally the first-line away from “Peggy away from Darby” is within a medley on the p. 284.
Lyle along with wrote another track to your song, offered throughout the performs cited, and published prior to that have tunes
T. Crofton Crocker on the Common Sounds of Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 off 1886 reprint), states, “The brand new quite Housemaid out-of Derby, O!” is known to be the production of an Irishman, but be brings zero details whichever, not mentioning in which a duplicate of one’s text message or song might be receive. It would appear that Crocker questioned his members getting familiar toward track and you can tune. The data cited over eastmeeteast indeks prijave seems to me to getting somewhat definitive when deciding to take “Rather Peggy from Derby” as an enthusiastic Irish song and you may track. Without which evidence, not, there have been counterclaims. Wm. Chappell within the Sounds of the Olden Date , II, p. 771, indexed Crocker’s allege, but designed that song was not Irish, however, the guy provided no lead research. Chappell’s declaration one to Bunting refuted it’s in place of foundation. Bunting did not speak about the song, which is definitely not similar to saying the guy rejected it. Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs having Chappell within his breakdown of Irish Folk-music from inside the this new fifth ed. regarding Grove’s Dictionary , however, cites no proof expert or fraud, therefore we have no idea exactly what facts he had viewed, or no.
Lastly, two products We have not but really seen. There can be a copy of pay attention a flute teacher published by T. BUCEM listing zero backup with the on the United kingdom Countries.
Unrelated: “Falls regarding Brandy” is a much earlier unrelated track of equivalent term, also known as “Dribbles away from Brandy.” The latter term Thomson’s tune into the listen their Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Distressed Gallant’, 1738. A few years later on that it tune was copied towards the NLS MS 6299. The new song you are going to violation into original one to for the tune whenever we did not remember that brand new track are before. “The latest Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s track to possess his song “Younger May Moonlight” inside 5th level of Irish Melodies , n.d. are a new listen 6/8 date that have similar name, plainly given by Moore in the chorus regarding a song when you look at the Robin Bonnet where in fact the tune checked in the place of term.